One of the best and worst aspects of studying art or going into the art major is critique.
Critique format would run as follows:
You work on a drawing for two weeks, spending 1, 2, 3, 16 hours on it
On critique day, you hang your drawing on a wall next to all of the other pieces of other students.
The professor and your peers go one by one, talking about and critiquing each piece on the wall.
You aren’t allowed to talk during the critique of your work. You cannot verbally defend or support the critique statements that your peers or professor are giving.
Critiques could go well or poorly depending on about a billion x factors: whose piece was next to yours, what the professor ate that morning, who your peers were, if it was sunny outside or not.
In critique of my own drawings and paintings in school, what I noticed was people would say almost the exact opposite of what I had hoped or envisioned.
At some points I got angry and at some points I also cried, but then eventually, I realized the point was to just expose myself and my work to judgement over and over. The point was to be vulnerable, so that eventually you could be tough - and not tough in a dumb turtleshell way, but tough in a sophisticated, smart way.
The challenge is that you might have to be insane, or incredibly tenacious, to keep going in art. After being told their painting sucks, a painting that they’d delicately painted for 40 hours, most people would quit, drop out, or give up.
The good thing about art critique is that at least you are in the same boat as 20 others, each who have tried to take their best shot.
Outside of the art-school world, people who are NOT artists will take cheap shots at your work and ideas. They won’t believe in your vision. Your plans won’t make any sense to them. They will lodge judgements, and basically say whatever they want.
I think this is actually okay - judgement is going to happen and it will never stop.
The point is to keep going despite all of this and to pursue work that makes you a happy and satisfied person, no matter what people say.
Strangely, it is this give-no-fucks mentality, this freedom, that makes the best art.
This is the point of any kind of art education, be it at an institution or not, and it’s most valuable cornerstone.
Keep believing.
Related blogs:
The Artificial Intelligence Engine of Clip Studio Paint
Overcoming Negative Self Talk as an Artist
Who Wrote This:
I’m a painter, I make comics, and sometimes I do computer stuff!
- Becky Jewell